,

In Text Citations: Harvard and APA 7 Rules for SA (2026)

In Text Citations: Harvard and APA 7 Rules for SA (2026)

In text citations are the small brackets that carry most of the weight of academic honesty in your dissertation. Each one tells the examiner whose idea you are using and where to find it, and a chapter with vague, missing or inconsistent citations is one of the fastest ways to collect corrections. South African universities mostly use Harvard or APA 7, and the two handle in-text citations slightly differently. This guide sets out the rules for both side by side, with examples for every situation you will meet in a literature review: two authors, three or more, quotations, secondary sources, organisations, personal communications and several sources at once. If you are building the chapter as you go, Tesify helps you structure your dissertation chapter by chapter.

What in text citations must do

Every in-text citation has two jobs. It credits the author for an idea, finding or wording, and it points the reader to the matching entry in your reference list. Both Harvard and APA are author-date systems, so the citation is short (surname and year) and the full details live in the list at the end. If a citation does not match a list entry exactly, it has failed at its second job.

Before applying any example below, check which style your faculty requires. South African universities publish their own Harvard variations, and some departments use APA 7. Our comparison of Harvard vs APA at South African universities explains which faculties tend to use which.

The two forms: narrative and parenthetical

Both styles allow two ways of placing a citation in a sentence. The University of the Western Cape’s Harvard guide calls them author-prominent and information-prominent; APA 7 guides, such as the University of Cambridge Education Library’s, call them narrative and parenthetical.

Form Harvard (UWC example) APA 7 (Cambridge example)
Name outside brackets (narrative / author-prominent) Callaway (2021) reports that… Garofalo (2013) describes the role played by the academic library…
Name inside brackets (parenthetical / information-prominent) …newer COVID variants (Callaway 2021). …a vital role in the community (Garofalo, 2013).

Notice the comma. APA 7 places a comma between the author and the year inside brackets; many South African Harvard variations do not. That one character is the most visible sign of whether you have followed your guide consistently.

Use the narrative form when the author matters to your argument (comparing studies, critiquing a method). Use the parenthetical form when the finding matters more than who reported it. Varying the two, and choosing precise reporting verbs, is what makes a literature review read as synthesis rather than a list.

Number of authors

Authors APA 7 Harvard (typical South African; check your guide)
One (Garofalo, 2013) (Callaway 2021)
Two (Brundrett & Rhodes, 2011) in brackets; Brundrett and Rhodes (2011) in a sentence (Mhlula & Letty 2015); Mhlula and Letty (2015)
Three or more First author plus et al. in every citation, even the first: (Smith et al., 2015) Varies: some guides list all authors at first citation up to a limit; many use et al. from three or four authors

The Cambridge APA 7 guide is explicit that for three or more authors you include only the first author’s name plus “et al.” in every citation, even the first, and that two-author citations use an ampersand in brackets but “and” spelled out in a sentence. It also advises avoiding possessive phrasing with et al.: write “Smith et al. (2015) found that…” rather than “Smith et al.’s findings”. If two different works would shorten to the same et al. citation, APA requires you to add authors until they differ.

Student comparing two printed style guides side by side at a desk with a laptop
Pick one style and apply its punctuation everywhere: the comma alone gives away inconsistency.

Direct quotations and page numbers

Every direct quotation needs a locator. The two styles differ in format:

  • APA 7 uses “p.”: (Garofalo, 2013, p. 3), or Garofalo (2013) states that “…” (p. 3). For audiovisual sources, Cambridge’s guide notes you give a time stamp instead.
  • Harvard in many South African guides uses a colon: (Gibson 2018:1), or Gibson (2018:1) states that…

Keep quotations short and purposeful. A dissertation that quotes heavily looks like it is avoiding analysis. Quote when the exact wording matters (a definition, a policy clause, a striking claim you will critique); otherwise paraphrase in your own words and cite. Many supervisors also expect page numbers for paraphrases of a specific passage or statistic.

Secondary sources: “as cited in”

Sometimes you read about a study in another author’s work and cannot get the original. The Cambridge APA guide’s advice is the standard one: read and reference the original wherever possible; if you cannot, put the source you actually read in your reference list and use “as cited in” in the text. Its example: “MacGilchrist argues that… (as cited in Brundrett & Rhodes, 2011, p. 99)”, with only Brundrett and Rhodes in the reference list.

Harvard variations handle this with wording such as “cited in” or “quoted in”; follow your guide. Keep secondary citations rare. A literature review full of them tells the examiner you have not read the key studies yourself, and for any source central to your argument, your library’s interlibrary loan service is the better route.

Organisations, Acts and no-author sources

  • Organisation as author: use the full name, for example (Department of Higher Education and Training, 2024) in APA. Some guides allow an abbreviation after the first citation if you define it.
  • No date: use n.d., for example (Zinn, n.d.) in UWC’s Harvard guide. Look hard for a date first.
  • Acts and case law: South African legislation and judgments follow dedicated formats; see our guide on citing South African Acts and case law.
  • AI tools: if your faculty requires you to acknowledge generative AI use, our guide to citing ChatGPT in Harvard and APA covers the formats.

Several sources for one point

When two or more studies support the same claim, cite them together in one set of brackets, separated by semicolons. APA 7 orders them alphabetically by first author; Harvard guides differ (alphabetical or chronological), so check yours. Use multiple citations to show consensus, but do not pile up six sources on a general statement to look thorough. Two or three well-chosen sources make a stronger case, and our guide to how many sources a master’s dissertation should cite puts the numbers in context.

Personal communications and interviews

Emails, conversations and other personal communications that a reader cannot retrieve are treated differently from published sources: APA-based guides generally cite them in the text only, while some Harvard variations also list them. Check your guide before you use one, and use them sparingly. This is different from your own research participants: interview data from your study are not cited as personal communications at all. They are reported in your findings with participant codes such as P4, according to your ethics approval.

Close-up of a hand adding a small pencil note in the margin of a printed draft chapter
Place each citation next to the claim it supports, not at the end of your own argument.

Where to place the citation in a sentence

Place the citation as close as possible to the claim it supports. If a sentence combines your own argument with a source’s finding, put the citation straight after the finding, not at the end of the sentence:

Throughput in honours programmes is relatively stable (Author, 2023), but this does not mean that research report supervision is adequate, which is the gap this study addresses. (Illustrative.)

The citation covers the first claim only; the second half is your argument. Examiners look for exactly this separation between what sources say and what you conclude.

When you discuss one source across several sentences, you do not need to repeat the citation in every sentence if it is obvious you are still talking about the same work. Re-cite it when you return to it after discussing something else, or when a paragraph break could leave the reader unsure.

The same paragraph in Harvard and APA 7 (illustrative)

Seeing one paragraph in both styles makes the differences easy to spot. All authors, years and claims in this example are invented for illustration; only the punctuation patterns matter.

Harvard (South African colon convention)

Academic libraries are often described as community institutions rather than storage spaces (Dlamini 2013). Botha and Naidoo (2011:99) go further, arguing that leadership quality depends on how schools use evidence, while Nkosi et al. (2022) show that this link is weaker in under-resourced settings. Taken together, these studies suggest that access alone does not change practice.

APA 7

Academic libraries are often described as community institutions rather than storage spaces (Dlamini, 2013). Botha and Naidoo (2011, p. 99) go further, arguing that leadership quality depends on how schools use evidence, while Nkosi et al. (2022) show that this link is weaker in under-resourced settings. Taken together, these studies suggest that access alone does not change practice.

Three differences are visible: the comma after the author in parenthetical citations, the page locator (colon versus “p.”), and the treatment of et al. (some Harvard guides italicise it; APA 7 does not). The final sentence carries no citation in either version, because it is the writer’s own synthesis.

Common in-text citation mistakes in South African dissertations

  • Initials or first names in the citation. In-text citations use surnames only, unless two authors share a surname and your guide asks for initials to tell them apart.
  • Titles instead of authors. “According to the article on school leadership…” is not a citation; name the author and year.
  • Citing the database, search engine or website host rather than the author of the document.
  • Dropping the year in narrative citations when the author is mentioned a second time in a new paragraph.
  • Mixing the two styles because sources were copied from different places, so some citations have commas and others do not.
  • Citing everything at the end of a paragraph, which hides which source supports which claim.

In-text citation checklist before you submit

  1. One style throughout, matching your faculty guide.
  2. Consistent punctuation: comma or no comma between author and year, & or and, p. or colon.
  3. Every direct quotation has a page number or time stamp.
  4. Et al. used at the threshold your style sets, with no possessives after it.
  5. Every citation matches a reference list entry exactly: spelling, year, a/b suffixes.
  6. Secondary citations are rare and marked correctly.
  7. Participant quotations use codes, not names, and are not cited as personal communications.

If your list and your citations have drifted apart, our step-by-step fix for a reference list that does not match the faculty guide shows how to repair it.

FAQ

What is the difference between Harvard and APA in text citations?

Both are author-date. APA 7 puts a comma between author and year, (Garofalo, 2013), and uses p. for pages. Many South African Harvard guides omit the comma and use a colon for pages, (Gibson 2018:1).

When do I use et al. in APA 7?

For three or more authors, use the first author plus et al. in every citation, including the first one.

Do I need a page number for a paraphrase?

Direct quotations always need one. For paraphrases, it depends on your guide and supervisor, but adding it for a specific passage or statistic is good practice.

How do I cite a source I found in another book?

Use a secondary citation such as (as cited in Brundrett & Rhodes, 2011, p. 99) and list only the source you actually read.

Do I cite my interview participants as personal communications?

No. Data from your own participants are reported in your findings with participant codes, as approved by your ethics committee.

Can Tesify add my in-text citations?

No. Tesify helps you structure your dissertation chapter by chapter. Your citations and the text stay your own work, 100% written by you.

Structure your dissertation with Tesify

Citations are easier to manage when every section has a clear purpose. 50,000+ students have written 230,000+ chapters with Tesify, which helps you structure your dissertation chapter by chapter, and every word stays 100% written by you. Structure your dissertation with Tesify.

Sources cited

  • University of Cambridge, Education Library (n.d.) Referencing Guide APA 7th: How to Write In-text Citations. Available at: libguides.cam.ac.uk.
  • University of the Western Cape Library (n.d.) Referencing: Harvard: In-text citations. Available at: libguides.uwc.ac.za.